Module 4: Teaching Listening and Speaking
Module Overview
This module focuses on developing the oral/aural skills essential for effective communication in English. We will explore the nature of listening and speaking processes, examine challenges learners face with these skills, and investigate practical approaches for teaching them. You will learn strategies for designing engaging listening activities, techniques for developing fluency and accuracy in speaking, and methods for integrating these skills in meaningful communicative contexts.
Learning Objectives
By the end of this module, you will be able to:
- Explain the cognitive processes involved in listening comprehension and oral production.
- Design effective pre-listening, while-listening, and post-listening activities.
- Implement strategies for developing both fluency and accuracy in speaking.
- Select and adapt appropriate listening materials for different proficiency levels.
- Create opportunities for meaningful communication in the classroom.
- Address common challenges in teaching listening and speaking.
- Integrate listening and speaking with other language skills.
4.1 Understanding Listening in Language Learning
Listening is a complex, active process that involves much more than simply hearing sounds.
The Listening Process
Effective listening involves several cognitive processes:
- Perception: Recognizing sounds, stress patterns, and intonation.
- Parsing: Breaking the sound stream into meaningful units (words, phrases).
- Utilization: Connecting what is heard to existing knowledge to construct meaning.
- Prediction: Anticipating what might come next based on context and knowledge.
- Inferencing: Understanding implied meanings and filling in unstated information.
Types of Listening
- Intensive Listening: Focused attention on specific language features (pronunciation, grammar, vocabulary).
- Extensive Listening: Listening for general understanding and enjoyment (similar to extensive reading).
- Interactive Listening: Participating in conversations where listening and speaking alternate.
- Selective Listening: Focusing on specific information while ignoring other parts.
- Critical Listening: Evaluating what is heard for credibility, bias, or persuasive techniques.
Challenges in L2 Listening
- Speech Rate: Natural speech often seems too fast for learners.
- Connected Speech: Words blend together in natural speech (linking, assimilation, elision).
- Vocabulary Limitations: Unknown words can block comprehension.
- Accent Variation: Different accents can be difficult to understand.
- Background Knowledge: Lack of cultural or contextual knowledge can impede understanding.
- Cognitive Load: Processing meaning while keeping up with ongoing input.
- Attention and Concentration: Maintaining focus, especially for extended periods.
Self-Reflection Activity
Think about your own experience listening to a foreign language (or if English is not your first language, listening to English). Which of the challenges listed above do you find most difficult? What strategies have helped you overcome these challenges? How might this insight inform your teaching?
4.2 Approaches to Teaching Listening
Effective listening instruction typically follows a three-phase approach:
Pre-listening Phase
Activities before listening that prepare students and activate relevant knowledge:
- Setting Context: Providing background information, discussing the topic.
- Activating Prior Knowledge: Brainstorming what students already know about the topic.
- Predicting Content: Using titles, images, or keywords to predict what will be heard.
- Pre-teaching Vocabulary: Introducing key words that might block comprehension.
- Setting Purpose: Clarifying why students are listening and what they should focus on.
While-listening Phase
Activities during listening that guide comprehension and focus attention:
- Global Listening: Identifying main ideas, speakers, context, or purpose.
- Selective Listening: Identifying specific information (names, numbers, facts).
- Detailed Listening: Understanding specific details and nuances.
- Inferential Listening: Drawing conclusions about implied meanings.
- Note-taking: Recording key information in an organized way.
Post-listening Phase
Activities after listening that extend understanding and connect to other skills:
- Checking Comprehension: Verifying understanding through questions or discussions.
- Analyzing Language: Examining vocabulary, grammar, or discourse features.
- Personalizing: Relating content to students' own experiences or opinions.
- Extending: Using the listening content as a springboard for speaking or writing.
- Reflecting: Discussing strategies used and challenges faced.
Selecting Listening Materials
Consider these factors when choosing listening texts:
- Authenticity: Authentic materials vs. graded/adapted materials.
- Length: Appropriate duration for learner level and task.
- Content: Relevance, interest, cultural appropriateness.
- Linguistic Complexity: Vocabulary, grammar, speech rate, accent.
- Task Potential: Possibilities for meaningful pre/while/post activities.
Lesson Planning Activity
Choose a short listening text appropriate for a specific level (e.g., a news report, conversation, podcast excerpt). Design a complete listening lesson following the three-phase approach. Include at least two activities for each phase (pre-listening, while-listening, post-listening), ensuring they are appropriate for your chosen level and text.
4.3 Understanding Speaking in Language Learning
Speaking is a complex productive skill that involves multiple cognitive and physical processes.
The Speaking Process
Producing spoken language involves several stages:
- Conceptualization: Deciding what to say and planning the message.
- Formulation: Selecting vocabulary and grammatical structures.
- Articulation: Physically producing sounds, stress, and intonation.
- Self-monitoring: Checking and correcting one's own speech.
Dimensions of Speaking Proficiency
- Accuracy: Correctness of language forms (grammar, vocabulary, pronunciation).
- Fluency: Smoothness, pace, and natural flow of speech.
- Complexity: Use of varied and sophisticated language structures.
- Appropriacy: Suitability of language for context, purpose, and audience.
- Range: Variety of language functions, vocabulary, and structures.
Types of Speaking Activities
- Imitative: Repeating words or phrases to practice pronunciation.
- Intensive: Practicing specific language features in controlled contexts.
- Responsive: Participating in short dialogues or exchanges.
- Interactive: Engaging in longer conversations or discussions.
- Extensive: Delivering monologues, presentations, or speeches.
Challenges in L2 Speaking
- Performance Anxiety: Fear of making mistakes or being judged.
- Limited Vocabulary: Struggling to find the right words.
- Pronunciation Difficulties: Unfamiliar sounds, stress patterns, or intonation.
- Grammar Uncertainty: Hesitation due to concerns about accuracy.
- Processing Pressure: Need to plan and produce language simultaneously.
- L1 Interference: Influence of first language patterns.
- Lack of Practice: Limited opportunities for authentic communication.
Case Study Analysis
Consider this scenario: In your intermediate adult class, you have several students who understand English well but rarely speak. When they do speak, their language is often accurate but very hesitant and limited. Based on the information above, what might be causing their reluctance to speak? What specific approaches might help these students develop their speaking skills?
4.4 Approaches to Teaching Speaking
Effective speaking instruction balances controlled practice with communicative activities:
Developing Pronunciation
- Segmental Features: Individual sounds (vowels, consonants).
- Suprasegmental Features: Stress, rhythm, intonation, linking.
- Techniques:
- Listen and repeat exercises
- Minimal pair practice
- Phonetic training (mouth positions, voicing)
- Shadowing (repeating immediately after a model)
- Jazz chants and songs for rhythm and stress
- Recording and self-analysis
Balancing Fluency and Accuracy
Different activities emphasize different aspects of speaking:
- Accuracy-focused Activities:
- Controlled practice with specific structures
- Guided dialogues and role-plays
- Sentence pattern drills
- Explicit correction and feedback
- Fluency-focused Activities:
- Free discussions and conversations
- Information gap tasks
- Timed speaking challenges
- 4/3/2 technique (repeating the same talk in decreasing time)
- Delayed error correction
Types of Speaking Activities
Activity Type | Description | Examples |
---|---|---|
Information Gap | Students exchange information that only they possess | Find the differences, jigsaw tasks, spot the lie |
Discussion & Debate | Expressing and defending opinions on topics | Formal debates, small group discussions, ranking tasks |
Role-plays & Simulations | Taking on roles in simulated scenarios | Job interviews, customer service, travel situations |
Presentations | Prepared talks on specific topics | Mini-presentations, show and tell, instructional talks |
Storytelling | Creating or retelling narratives | Picture stories, personal anecdotes, chain stories |
Games & Challenges | Playful activities with speaking components | 20 Questions, Taboo, Just a Minute, Alibi |
Scaffolding Speaking
Providing support structures to help learners succeed:
- Linguistic Scaffolds: Vocabulary banks, useful phrases, sentence starters.
- Content Scaffolds: Visual aids, examples, models, planning time.
- Task Scaffolds: Clear instructions, demonstrations, structured formats.
- Procedural Scaffolds: Think-pair-share, preparation time, rehearsal.
Activity Design Challenge
Design a 15-20 minute speaking activity for a specific level (beginner, intermediate, or advanced). Your activity should:
- Have a clear communicative purpose
- Include appropriate scaffolding for your chosen level
- Balance fluency and accuracy appropriately
- Engage all students (not just a few)
Describe the activity, materials needed, procedure, and how you would handle feedback.
4.5 Common Challenges and Solutions
Both listening and speaking instruction present specific challenges that require thoughtful solutions:
Listening Challenges and Solutions
Challenge | Solution |
---|---|
Students find authentic materials too difficult | Grade the task, not the text; provide more scaffolding; use shorter segments; pre-teach key vocabulary |
Students want to understand every word | Teach listening strategies; emphasize gist listening; build confidence with easier tasks first |
Limited exposure to different accents | Gradually introduce variety; use videos with visual support; provide accent awareness activities |
Students struggle with connected speech | Explicit teaching of linking, reduction, etc.; dictation activities; focused listening for specific features |
Difficulty maintaining attention | Use shorter texts; provide engaging tasks; vary listening formats; include visual support |
Speaking Challenges and Solutions
Challenge | Solution |
---|---|
Students are reluctant to speak | Create a supportive atmosphere; use pair work before full-class speaking; provide preparation time |
Uneven participation (some dominate, others silent) | Use structured turn-taking; assign roles; implement think-pair-share; use small groups |
L1 use during activities | Set clear expectations; create English-only zones; provide necessary language support |
Students focus too much on accuracy and hesitate | Designate fluency-focused activities where mistakes don't matter; build confidence gradually |
Pronunciation issues affect comprehensibility | Focus on high-priority features that affect understanding; provide targeted practice; use recording/feedback |
Research by Nation & Newton (2009) found that students who practiced listening before speaking performed better in conversation tasks, highlighting the importance of integrated skills instruction.
Reflection Question
What is the biggest challenge your students face (or that you anticipate they would face) with listening or speaking? What specific strategies from this section might help address this challenge? Is there another approach not mentioned here that you've found effective?
4.6 Integrating Listening and Speaking
Listening and speaking naturally complement each other and are often integrated in real-life communication. Effective instruction recognizes this connection:
Benefits of Integration
- Authenticity: Reflects real-world communication patterns.
- Reinforcement: Skills support and strengthen each other.
- Efficiency: Maximizes learning time by addressing multiple skills.
- Motivation: Creates meaningful, purposeful communication contexts.
- Transfer: Facilitates application of language across modalities.
Integrated Activity Types
- Listen and Respond: Listening to questions, instructions, or information and providing spoken responses.
- Listen and Repeat/Reformulate: Reproducing or paraphrasing what was heard.
- Listen and Discuss: Using listening content as a springboard for conversation.
- Information Gap: Exchanging information through speaking and listening.
- Dictogloss: Reconstructing a text collaboratively after listening.
- Interviews: Gathering information through questioning and listening.
- Debates and Discussions: Listening to others' views and responding.
Sample Integrated Lesson: Asking for Directions
- Warm-up (5 min): Show a map and ask students about their experiences finding their way in unfamiliar places.
- Pre-listening (10 min): Teach key direction phrases and vocabulary. Have students predict what phrases might appear in conversations about directions.
- Listening Activity (15 min):
- Play a recording of someone asking for and giving directions.
- Students complete a map by drawing the route described.
- Check comprehension by comparing maps.
- Speaking Practice (15 min):
- Controlled practice: Students practice key phrases in pairs.
- Semi-controlled practice: Using map prompts, students take turns asking for and giving directions.
- Communicative Task (10 min): Students move around the classroom asking for directions to hidden objects, following the directions given by classmates.
- Reflection & Extension: Students discuss challenges they faced and strategies they used. For homework, they record themselves giving directions to a local landmark.
Integrated Lesson Planning
Design a 45-60 minute integrated listening and speaking lesson on a topic of your choice. Your lesson should include:
- A clear language focus (functions, vocabulary, or structures)
- Both listening and speaking components that build on each other
- A progression from more controlled to more communicative activities
- Appropriate support for your target learners
Outline the stages of your lesson, key activities, and approximate timing.
4.7 Module Summary and Key Takeaways
- Listening is an active, complex process involving perception, parsing, and utilization of language input.
- Effective listening instruction follows a three-phase approach: pre-listening, while-listening, and post-listening.
- Speaking involves multiple cognitive processes and dimensions of proficiency, including accuracy, fluency, and appropriacy.
- Speaking activities should be scaffolded appropriately and progress from more controlled to more communicative practice.
- Common challenges in listening and speaking can be addressed through targeted strategies and appropriate support.
- Integrating listening and speaking creates authentic communication contexts and reinforces both skills.
4.8 Assessment and Reflection
Quiz: Check Your Understanding
1. Which of the following is an example of extensive listening?
2. Why should teachers balance fluency and accuracy activities in speaking instruction?
3. Which is an example of a communicative speaking activity?
4. What is the primary purpose of pre-listening activities?
Reflection Journal Prompt
Based on what you've learned in this module, identify one specific technique or approach for teaching listening or speaking that you find particularly valuable. Why does this approach appeal to you, and how might you implement it in your teaching context? What challenges might you face, and how would you address them?
4.9 Additional Resources & Further Exploration
- Books:
- Teaching and Learning Second Language Listening – Christine Goh & Larry Vandergrift
- Teaching Speaking: A Holistic Approach – Christine Goh & Anne Burns
- How to Teach Listening – J.J. Wilson
- Teaching Pronunciation – Marianne Celce-Murcia et al.
- Websites:
- Digital Tools:
- Vocaroo – For recording and sharing speaking practice
- Flipgrid – For video-based speaking assignments and feedback
- Lyricstraining – For music-based listening practice
- TED Talks – For authentic listening material with transcripts